It is difficult to rate, as it obviously does not strive to be a professional instrument. It is not that nice to play (comes off as an above-average toy)), but good enough as a “test” for a young kid to see whether music and stringed instruments are of interest. And it does not cost very much. So depending on expectations, I could give it anywhere from 1 to 5. I take the middle road, and note that the 1y old who got it, was ecstatic!