I almost feel bad lumbering this strap with a 3* rating. The reason being that it isn't a bad product. It's well made, actually of pretty high quality.
The problem I had is that I just couldn't get used to a strap that has so much give. The elasticated nature of the strap just means that the guitar has more room to manoeuvre than I'm used to and I personally found it unnatural.
But...
That is a very subjective opinion. For some that will be exactly what they want and if that's you then I'd say you'd be very pleased with this strap.
In fact, I've just talked myself into upgrading my rating from 3* to 4*. It is, after all, a good product, even if it isn't quite to my taste.